All use cases
Free Shipping by Mistake · Integrity · already happened
  1. 01How it is found
  2. 02What you see
  3. 03What you do next
  4. 04The money
  5. 05In both engines' views
  6. 06On from the start

A $15 product, shipped free. Shipping cost $15.

Free shipping should start at a threshold. An order under it shipped free anyway, and the carrier still sent a bill. Otiox compares orders with the free-shipping threshold in your shipping rates and shows the carrier cost you paid.
app.otiox.comFig. 00
Integrity · margin
Free shipping under the $75 threshold
Order · shipping charged $0
SignalMeasuredValue
Order valuethreshold $75$15.00
Shipping charged$0.00
Carrier costrecorded$15.00
Shipping you paid: $15
What to do

Check the order's shipping charge and the shop's shipping rules.

Orders under the threshold pay for shipping.

01The Challenge

Free for the customer. Not for you.

For example: free shipping starts at $75. A $15 order paid nothing for shipping and the carrier charged $15. A discount code, a channel setting or a manual order skipped the rule, and the whole margin went to the carrier.
  1. 01
    Discount codes override shipping rules
  2. 02
    Channels have their own shipping settings
  3. 03
    Manual orders skip the threshold
  4. 04
    The carrier bill arrives later, separately
02SEE IT IN OTIOX

The same situation, in the product.

Real screens from the Otiox demo workspace, step by step.
  1. 01

    The finding, and how it happened

    The Integrity Engine's finding names the record and what to do, and its cascade shows how it reached the money. Check the order's shipping charge and the shop's shipping rules: often a discount code or a channel setting.

    The finding, and how it happened
  2. 02

    Where the margin goes

    On the order, the waterfall runs from price through discount, goods cost, shipping not paid by the customer, payment fees and refunds to the true margin, and names the biggest leak.

    Where the margin goes
  3. 03

    On, shadow or off

    The scenario's row on the Scenario switches page: how many findings are open, and its switch. It is on from the start; shadow keeps it counting without raising findings.

    On, shadow or off
03

How It Works

Purpose-built features that solve these exact problems.
01

How it is found

Orders with a shipping charge of 0, a recorded carrier cost above 0, and an order value under the lowest free-shipping threshold in your shipping rate templates.
02

What you see

The Risk Inbox line "Free shipping on order {n} under the $75 threshold" with an Open order button; the waterfall shows "Shipping not paid by the customer" as the biggest leak.
03

What you do next

Check the order's shipping charge and the shop's shipping rules: often a discount code or a channel setting.
04

The money

The carrier cost of the order.
05

In both engines' views

The finding appears in the Integrity Engine with its cascade from the record to the money, in the Risk Inbox and in the Loss Prevention Report.
06

On from the start

The scenario is on by default. Put it in shadow to keep it counting on the margin scenarios screen, with a six-month backtest, without raising findings, or switch it off.
04

What You'll Gain

Tangible improvements that impact your bottom line.
  1. 01
    The rule behind the mistake

    Each order points to the code or setting that gave shipping away.

  2. 02
    Carrier cost in money

    You see what each free shipment cost.

  3. 03
    Counted with every other loss

    Margin findings feed the Loss Prevention Report next to the other engine findings.

  4. 04
    Nothing changes by itself

    No scenario changes a price, a discount or an order. You decide.

05

Real-World Scenarios

See how this works in practice.
Scenario 1

Shipped free

A $15 order pays $0 shipping; the carrier charges $15.
Scenario 2

Flagged

The finding names the order and the $75 threshold it is under.
Scenario 3

Fixed

The discount code that removed shipping is limited to orders above the threshold.
06

The Transformation

From chaos to clarity.
Before
  • Thresholds bypassed
  • Carrier bills unmatched
  • Margin gone on small orders
  • Cause never found
After
  • Orders checked against the threshold
  • Carrier cost shown
  • Biggest leak named on the order
  • Rule fixed at the source
07

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers to common questions.
01Where does the threshold come from?
From the lowest free-shipping threshold in your shipping rate templates.
02What if no carrier cost is recorded?
Then this check does not fire: it needs a real carrier cost above zero.
03Who sees the numbers?
Cost and margin figures are shown only to people with cost or accounting rights.
04Does Otiox change prices or orders?
No. No scenario changes a price, a discount or an order. It raises the finding and opens the record; the decision is yours.
05Can I put it in shadow or switch it off?
Yes. Every scenario is on from the start. Per scenario, you can put it in shadow (it keeps counting on the margin scenarios screen, with a six-month backtest, but raises nothing) or switch it off, on the margin card or the Scenario switches page. Thresholds are workspace settings.
06Which currency are the amounts in?
Your books currency, at the store's own rate. With no rate, the amount is left empty, never guessed. VAT is taken out before margins; test, cancelled, refunded, draft and abandoned orders are left out.
Free Shipping by Mistake

Ready to transform your free shipping by mistake?

See how Otiox can solve your specific challenges.